I stumbled on Isabel Klee on one of my Instagram-reeling marathons (@Simonsits). She seemed like a nice, young woman who fosters dogs and documents their stories on Instagram. She lives in Brooklyn, which I recognized from my visits to my brother and enjoyed seeing again. I’ve liked her Instagram stories for awhile now. The publicity she brings to her rescue dogs and the rescue organizations she works with bring in a fair bit of money and many potential adopters. Every time she works with partners to advertise things on Instagram, she donates some of that money.
So, when I saw Dogs, Boys, and Other Things I’ve Cried About (2026) by Klee, I figured it might be fun to read. I’d heard that she had worked for The Dogist (another NYC-based, social media, dog person), and I was curious about the details. I was also curious how she came to have her dog, Simon, and how he changed her life. In addition, I’d seen Isabel’s fiancé on Instagram, and I was curious about their story. I used Audible to listen to the Audiobook, which is read by Klee.
Unfortunately, I was a little disappointed in this book because it wasn’t what I was expecting. I wanted to like this book because I liked Klee from Instagram, but there wasn’t enough detail for me. If I’m going to read a memoir, then I want to really understand what makes them tick and how they became who they are. Although I superficially learned about some of Klee’s previous relationships, I didn’t really get a sense of who she was. Many of the dogs that she discusses in her book, I’d seen on Instagram, so she’d taken care of them relatively recently. But she has them interspersed throughout the book with mini lessons of what we can learn from them. I found I enjoyed their stories more through videos and pictures than reading about them.
Klee writes that she dropped out of college and moved to New York City, something she’s always wanted since growing up in New Jersey. She lives in a number of not great apartments with various roommates and dates men who are not great for her–at least two of them cheated on her. I was interested to hear how she adopted Simon, and when she found out that he had a seizure disorder. It was also interesting to see what she thought about her now-fiancé when she first met him.
It’s hard for me to describe what put me off this book. First, I do wish I could have understood her trajectory better. Although she mentions working for Elias for many years (the dogist), there was very little detail about what she did for him besides a couple short stories here and there. I had assumed that it was her work with Elias that led her to developing her own social media platforms, but she never talks about it. Second, I wish Klee had been more specific when discussing her relationships. She would mention an ex-boyfriend and that they had problems, but there were never enough details for me to really see what was happening. Even when she has problems with her current fiancé, she says that she pushed him away because he wasn’t crazy about her, then she went to therapy and it was better. It is certainly her right to only divulge what she is comfortable divulging, but I found it frustrating and difficult to relate to. Instead, she used generic descriptions about love and friendship and lessons learned that were hard to hear from someone younger than me without the details to back it up.
I enjoy Klee’s content, and I wanted to enjoy this book, but it just wasn’t for me.
You can find all my reviews on my blog.
