No Ivy League by Hazel Newlevant was not what I expected from what I had read about it and the cover. Hazel’s story is a coming of age story, which is not a new theme. However, the way Newlevant presents it feels fresh. The graphic novel has an odd cover look to it. First it looks like it is going to be about a middle schooler or young highschooler, but for the middle school age. But then it looks more teen and for the 15 and up crowd. And after reading it, I would not recommend it for under aged 12, but more likely recommend it for at least 13 and up. There is some language (nothing kids haven’t seen or heard, but it is there) and the subjects and themes make for a relevant and mature read. There is talk about sexual harassment, privilege people do and don’t have, homeschooling vs. traditional schooling, crushes, race issues, and age differences in partners. However, even if you have not experienced these things, it is also relatable to most readers.
The illustrations were the weak spot for me, but work well for the story’s format and needs. They were black and white and not overly detailed. But, they could be crowded as there are scenes set in wooded areas. I know that colored illustrations are expensive, but it could have helped reinforce a few points and characters with a dash of color. I think that it would have made people more “seen” if you know what the details about them are. But then again, that is probably the point. Not to have preconceived feelings. Overall, things are well done, but I was not wowed. I think I need to explore other things that Newlevant has done to get a better understanding of their work and style. And a read again is not out of the question and recommended.
