Hot or Not: 20th-Century Male Artists by Jessica Campbell has so much wrong with this book that it’s right….for the right reader.
I’m not that reader.
Or maybe I was.
I mean I was totally into the concept of the book: what male artists are “boneable ” or not (sure there is a bit more to it, but that is what it boils down to). And sure, I can get into that as a joke that is a little off-color, as I don’t see any serious harm. It turns on its head the concept of men are always painting women, painting and thinking about sex, and the “boneablity” of women, so why not turn the tables?
But the thing is, the images are all black and white. So, first of all you can’t see what the paintings the narrator mentions (and shows to explain the “feeling” of sexual tension, mental state and boneability from that) look like.They mention orange or some feature that needs color or better detailing to portray the sentiment they want to portray and yeah, I can’t see it because it is literally not there. And the drawings of the artists themselves are okay, but again, nothing there really “defines” them for you to form your own opinion. I did know one artist and before the author/narrator came to their conclusion, I said that if they said Yes, he’s boneable, I would stop reading. Thankfully (or maybe not, depending on your thoughts of the book) I was able to read on. (Though I’ve heard the narrator and I might be in the minority on that.)
With all that said, and maybe this was the point after all, I did look up some of the actual artists to see what they created, what they looked like and any personal info that a quick internet search can dig up. And while I said there weren’t a lot of details to make you see the artist on the page, the photographs via the web brought up images that say Campbell hit the mark in a few cases. Or in other words, Campbell nailed it (or wouldn’t nail it. Him. Them. You know what I mean) for a few of them (though I think they were generous with one Yes).

