Someday Perfect: (A Graphic Novel) by Kat Schneider
Simple presentation, but it has deep questions. Lovely illustrations. Not for everyone (due to the religious aspects) but most can find something to enjoy. I would say at least 12 and up, but younger children could handle it if they are strong readers. There is some talk of sexual activities, the use of the word sl-t and the body shaming that comes with a patriarchal philosophy. But overall, it was tastefully done. It wasn’t a ‘WOW’ for me, but the right reader will definitely enjoy it.
And that concludes my not so grammatically correct overall review of Schneider’s debut graphic novel. I neither loved nor hated this book. I liked it. I enjoyed the coming together of things. However, there were holes in a few places for me. Not that it probably matters which religious group Schnedier is representing, but that would have been interesting, or at least I would have liked a more included philosophy outside of the few pieces we do get, but are important to the story arc. Also, I would have liked to have seen a little more background on the actual characters. Still, the main part comes through.
Which is A Woman’s Place and Coming Into Yourself, plus, how it is shaped by their religion.The idea of “Eve is the sinner” and “Adam can do no wrong” is quickly established, and the “Adams” of the story are never held accountable so this accounts for the fact that I’m not completely sure that Schneider is promoting a more feminist movement, but she does open the door a bit. Our main character only starts to question her faith little by little, but it is not until the end that she actually mentions how much she is questioning it. So, is she going to stay devot, follow the rules (even though they are not fair in many ways) or will she find a path that works for her. Regardless if it means leaving her faith behind? Again, I liked this book, just did not love it.
