Vanyel Ashkevron has never been the son that his father wanted, and he has never felt like he never belonged in his home at Forest Reach. After an attempt to prove that he can succeed at fighting, just in a different style than their weaponsmaster teaches, goes awry, Van finds himself packed off to the capitol Haven to be put under the care of his aunt, Herald-Mage Savil. What Van expects to be a prison and a punishment turns into a blessing in disguise. However, when tragedy strikes, Van will have to figure out how to become who he needs to be and the fate of Valdemar itself may rest on his shoulders.
This series was the fantasy first one I came across as a teenager that had a gay protagonist. My feelings about it have changed over the years in a lot of ways, but it was definitely a sliding glass door for me, showing me a possibility that I hadn’t really considered for myself. Lackey’s books were also the first ones where I saw same sex relationships portrayed in a way that was normalized. Van might be her first clearly LGBTQ+ protagonist, but there are same sex couples littered throughout her book, and it’s always portrayed as something normal even if other people have prejudices against it.
Van goes through it in these books. Though he does get moments of happiness, he suffers a lot. It’s almost like his arrogance and rudeness as a teen is punished tenfold for the rest of his life. If you’ve read the Arrows trilogy before reading this one, you know how his story ends, but it hits different when you really get to know Van. Especially a lot of what happens in Magic’s Price. These are some of the first books that really made me cry while reading them. While I do think that the final book goes a little overboard in torturing Van, overall, it works. For all that Vanyel has incredibly powers beyond most people, he’s very human at heart. He has quite a few flaws and numerous struggles, but that makes his triumphs all the sweeter. And I really relate to his struggles with isolation and loneliness, even though Van does eventually surround himself with a found family.
Van’s relationships, especially with Savil are one of the best things about the book. While it’s not necessarily a large circle of folks (though it’s probably more than Van realizes), it’s clear that Van gives his whole heart when he cares for folks and will do whatever he can to protect them. Even to his own detriment. But that goes both ways. He has more people that care for him than he realizes, and they make a huge impact on his life.
I’ve come to appreciate these books more as I’ve gotten older. As a teen, I found Van a little too angsty and the books too poignant. I’m still not a big fan of poignant, but I will reread these books on occasion. Van’s is one of the only Velgarth series that ends without an unequivocally happy ending. But Van is a great character and as I’ve gotten older I’ve come to appreciate him more. I’ve also worked with teens long enough now that I’ve seen a number of teens who’ve had family experiences like Van’s, and I have a lot more sympathy for him. I’ve also appreciated the fact that Van is forced to confront and work through a lot of his trauma and past experiences.
I’ve also had a change of heart on his romantic relationships and my opinions on his love interests. Avoiding too much in the way of spoilers, I was lukewarm on Van’s second love interest as a teen, but I’ve come around to really like him and appreciate what he brings to their relationship. While these books aren’t my favorites, I do hold a soft spot for them and enjoy revisiting them on occasion. Magic’s Pawn gets three out of five stars. Magic’s Promise and Magic’s Price get four out of five stars. The series as a whole gets four out of five stars.
Bingo – Versus – It’s Van versus so many things in these books.
