Bingo Square: refuge (the FMC asks the MMC for refuge in his kingdom)
This is another one of those romantasy novels that threw out some interesting ideas and world building but didn’t flesh out the details too much, and instead spent all of the time on the main characters. This can be fine if their interactions are engaging and they have chemistry but this story had some strong insta-love issues combined with a completely insufferable and petulant main character, Imogen. I actually liked Theo for the most part but he was also a bit bland/generic.
Imogen is a ward of the king in a kingdom that has become very militaristic in the recent years and turned away from the gods; they have hunted the sirens in their kingdom as part of their purge, and Imogen is a siren, hiding her true self. The king has promised her to the captain of his guard, but Imogen is cautiously hopeful; he seems to be at least nicer than the king and will allow her to get away from the castle. The same night a king is visiting from a neighboring kingdom, Imogen accidentally reveals her nature to her fiancée. He flips on her but decides he can use to his advantage and is about to force her to share a siren’s bond with him since it will give him his advantage against other sirens on their hunts. Things go very badly, and a forced/non-consensual bond is very much written as a metaphor for sexual assault and rape.
This is why it’s so frustrating that Imogen’s solution to her dilemma is to bind herself to the visiting king, Theo, and force him to take her with him when he leaves. She ultimately doesn’t do it, not because she makes the decision not to, but because Theo wakes up and gives her permission. Sorry, that isn’t enough – this character was about to commit the equivalent of rape to save herself and the only reason she didn’t is because the planned victim woke up. There needed to be clear moment when she decided not to before he gave permission if you still want me to like this character: moving a bit slowly because you know what you are about to do is wrong isn’t enough; if circumstances hadn’t gone her way, she would have been fine to non-consensually force this bond on someone.
Imogen escapes with Theo and then decides to be irritating for most of the novel; I guess the argument is that since she has spent her whole life going along with orders, now that she has taken a stand, she doesn’t want to do things without question anymore, but there still seems to be a balance she could have struck with sticking up for herself/making sure she understands what is being asked of herself and not making life anymore difficult for the guy who has just put his kingdom at risk for her and is trying to do damage control or prevent the situation from getting worse. But she is so self-absorbed and selfish that she’s upset the world doesn’t revolve around her and her questioning comes off as stupid and petulant bickering. Imogen is mad at one point that Theo didn’t compliment her when they are preparing to meet the woman he is trying to get engaged to for an alliance when obviously he doesn’t need her drawing attention to herself.
There are definitely the bones of what could have been an interesting story but so many of the characters are just rude to be rude, the interactions feel off, Imogen is incredibly inconsistent, the gods are just alluded to without going any deeper into this part of their world, and the couple didn’t work because the banter wasn’t bantering nor could I see what Theo saw in Imogen. I was so looking forward to a good siren story, too.
