The only life Mags has ever known is that of a mine slave, and it’s the only life he expects to know, as long as he survives, until a white horse shows up along with a Herald. Mags is whisked off to a new life as a Herald trainee, but his previous life means both that he is a fish out of water amongst the other trainees as well as having a lot to learn. Plus there is the mystery of where he came from. As Mags struggles to figure out his place in all of this, he also finds himself central to combating a new threat to the kingdom.
This series has great characters and great ideas, though the execution is sometimes lacking. The books were a quick read, and they sometimes suffered for that or lingered on things that seemed less important. One of the things that I did really like about the series is that it did a good job of showing the Hearlds as human beings who have good intentions but don’t always get things right as well as how they’re not a monolith when it comes to opinions on how things should be done. It’s also a both a different looks at what a Herald does as well as set at a time of transition for Valdemar itself.
Mags, Bear, and Lena all feel like real teenagers, and they grow over the course of the series, becoming more adult. They balance one another out well, and their relationships feel genuine. Amily is a great addition to their trio, and it’s nice to see her come more into herself over the course of the later books. The more minor characters as also really well sketched for the most part as well and help make up for when the plot is rather weak. It was neat to have many of the ones I thought were just one off characters pop back up later on in the books. I also liked getting to see more interaction between Healers, Heralds, and Bards, especially Bards. They’ve rarely had a large role in the Valdermar books before with the exception of Stefen from Vanyel’s books.
Mags is clearly going to be an atypical type of Herald from the start, and the focus on spycraft is a great focus. Nikolas is a great teacher, and it’s also clear that there’s strain between him both being a spymaster and being the King’s Own as his two roles pull him in different directions. Mags himself in a really interesting character in part because he can be a cypher at times even though the books are from his point of view for the most part. But he’s a great main character and his lack of understanding of how the world works outside of the mind means that reader sometimes gets more in depth information about the world than one would normally get.
The weakest part of this series is the pacing. It can feel incredibly uneven, and it might have done better if instead of five books, the volumes were combined to make three. They were quick reads though. At times it also feels like Lackey is setting the stage for things that don’t happen. I was surprised at where the series ended, though it is a good ending place. It’s just that there was a great potential for more stories with these characters and it seems like a waste to end things where they did. Because I’ve read almost all of the novels set in this world, I do know that this isn’t the end of Mags’ adventures, but I can see the ending putting off new readers, especially if this was the first Velgarth series that they read. I am looking forward to the continuing adventure of Mags though, especially now that he’ll be done with his training.
The first two books, Foundation and Intrigues were pretty strong, though the ending of the second book didn’t have a very satisfying emotional conclusion for me. I’d give Foundation four stars and Intrigues three stars. Changes also gets three stars from me; some of the characters seem out of character from their previous behavior, and there seems to have been very little learned from some of the events at the end of Intrigues. Redoubt is the weakest book in the series. It just barely scrapes by with a three stars, despite the plot tumor last third of the book that seems to come from nowhere. Bastion is a strong ending though and gets four out of five stars. Overall, I’d give this series three out of five stars.
Bingo – Friends – Mags’ friends play a huge role in this series.
