This coming-of-age novel showcases the intersection of ethnicity and sexuality against the recurring backdrop of McCarthyism. It appears to have been meticulously researched, which I appreciate. The novel centers on Lily Hu during the first half of her senior year in high school. She becomes closer to her classmate Kath while starting to discover her sexuality. Meanwhile, there are some concerns about the government’s interest in her father.
The plot will likely resonate with readers of all ages, but especially YA readers who tend to be grappling with identity and where they fit in. In the case of Lily, she’s “a good Chinese daughter,” which conflicts with her internal desires and her eventual behavior of sneaking out to visit the titular Telegraph Club. Malinda Lo’s writing feels accessible and true to how teenagers think and speak, and I really loved some of the lines, such as: “They had been in the same classes together for years, but it was as if they had been figurines in an automated diorama, moving on mechanical tracks that approached each other but never intersected until now.”
While I was immediately drawn into the book, it did start to feel slow. I enjoyed it while reading it but didn’t often feel compelled to pick it up. I’m not sure if this was a byproduct of the book itself or just my mood. However, I liked the characters (well, not so much Shirley) and seeing Lily’s growth, and the tone and various consequences that unfold seemed both realistic and hopeful. I’m glad I read it, and I recommend it.
