Cannonball Read 13

Sticking It to Cancer One Book at a Time

Search This Site

| Log in
  1. Follow us on Facebook
  2. Follow us on Twitter
  3. Follow us on Instagram
  4. Follow us on Goodreads
  5. RSS Feeds

  • Home
  • About
    • About CBR
    • Getting Started
    • Cannon Book Club
    • Diversions
    • Fan Mail
    • Holiday Book Exchange
    • Book Bingo Reading Challenge
    • Participation Badges
    • AlabamaPink
  • Our Team
    • Leaderboard
    • The CBR Team
    • Recent Comments
    • CBR Interviews
    • Our Volunteers
    • Meet MsWas
  • Categories
    • Review Genres
    • Tags
  • Fight Cancer
    • How We Fight Cancer
    • How You Can Donate
    • Book Sale
    • CBR Merchandise
    • Supporters and Friends of CBR
  • FAQ
  • Contact
    • Contact Form
    • Newsletter Sign Up
    • Newsletter Archive
    • Follow Us
> FAQ Home
> Genre: Fiction > A swing and a miss from Oprah.

A swing and a miss from Oprah.

American Dirt by Jeanine Cummins

September 19, 2020 by scootsa1000 6 Comments

I did not like this book.

I remember the weird Oprah controversy from last year, but honestly, didn’t pay too much attention to it while it was going on. And then my book club chose it for the summer selection. Most people loved it — regardless of the controversial story of Jeanine Cummins — but I couldn’t really get past her whole story and as I continued reading (well, listening), I got more and more annoyed with her and the story.

A quick overview of the Oprah thing: American Dirt was selected for Oprah’s book club, and after some original praise and good reviews, quickly started to be criticized for the fact that Cummins was a white trying to write about the plight of the Mexican migrant. Some Latinx authors and reviewers went so far as to call this book a “Mexican torture porn melodrama.” Lantix writers were furious that this book was getting so much attention and that it was written by a white woman, while writers from Mexico had been writing similar stories for years, and getting zero attention or publicity. Eventually, all of the criticism led to some interesting changes in the publishing world, hopefully leading to greater representation from some Latinx writers.

American Dirt is the story of Lydia, who owns a bookstore in Acapulco, and strikes up an intense friendship — which is almost love — with an older customer named Javier. She and Javier bond over books and poems, they talk about their families, they drink coffee and eat chocolate. They quickly become the most important person in each other’s lives, even though both are married and have a child.

Lydia’s husband, Sebastian, is a journalist who is focused on taking down the leaders of the horrific cartels in Acapulco, including the newest and worst, Los Jardineros.

Guess who is the ruthless and vicious head of Los Jardineros?

Yeah, so, the book starts out with Javier’s henchmen crashing a Quincinera for Lydia’s niece and slaughtering 15 members of her family, including Sebastian. Only Lydia and her son Luca survive, as they hid in the shower when the bullets started flying. (This isn’t a spoiler, it happens on the first page of the book.)

The rest of the story is flashbacks to Lydia and Javier’s time together mixed with Lydia and Luca’s attempt to make it across the border to the US.

Yes, some of the factual information was interesting. I had no idea that so many migrants would risk their lives by chasing freight trains and riding them as far north as they could. I didn’t know (although I could have guessed) how many robberies, rapes, and kidnappings occur on the route to the US. I appreciate the plight of these migrants, who are willing to do anything in order to have a potentially better life. I just hated how Janine Cummins chose to write about it.

Lydia should have been a sympathetic character. She literally lost everything at the hand of someone she loved. But I couldn’t stand her. As she and Luca (and the friends they made on their journey) hit problem after problem, I got so frustrated with her and with the never-ending awfulness of their journey.

SPOILERS: The part I hated the most was near the end when Lydia called Javier from Arizona, as they were hiking to safety with their Coyote. It just seemed like it was from another story about another woman. Suddenly so tough and full of daring rage, I didn’t buy the way that Lydia spoke to Javier at all.

I’m annoyed that I read this. I love my book club friends, but I’m going to hold this pick against them for a long time to come.

cbr12bingo: friendship

Filed Under: Fiction Tagged With: american dirt, cbr12, cbr12bingo, friendship, jeanine cummins, oprah, Scootsa1000

scootsa1000's CBR12 Review No:23 · Genres: Fiction · Tags: american dirt, cbr12, cbr12bingo, friendship, jeanine cummins, oprah, Scootsa1000 ·
Rating:
· 6 Comments

About scootsa1000

CBR13 participantCBR12 participantCBR11 participantCBR10 participantCBR  9CBR 8CBR 7CBR 6CBR 5CBR 4CBR 3

I've been kicking around since CBR3. View scootsa1000's reviews»

Comments

  1. andtheIToldYouSos says

    September 19, 2020 at 4:24 pm

    I will not be reading this book, and was ready to hate it from the onset of the controversy (the author and her barbed-wire print fingernails, ahhhhh), I had been waiting for a CBR person to roll through with a review and now I feel validated, haha. Thank you for hating it so I don’t have to read it!

    Reply
    • Scootsa1000 says

      September 19, 2020 at 5:30 pm

      I had no idea about her nails because I refused to google her. But that makes me want to punch her.

      Reply
      • narfna says

        September 21, 2020 at 1:49 pm

        Yes, she had her nails painted to look like her book cover, but I didn’t think that was as bad as whoever put together her book tour thinking it would be a cute idea to have barbed wire as decoration for the centerpieces.

        Reply
  2. ingres77 says

    September 20, 2020 at 9:55 am

    Legit question, the problem with this book is that a white woman wrote about non-white issues?

    Or is it that she did a bad job? Or is it that the praise for her work outshines the praise for more ethnically appropriate writers?

    I haven’t read this, and am only tangentially aware of the controversy surrounding it, but it seems (to me, at least) that the vitriol for this book is a lot stronger than, say, Steven Spielberg and Amistad (which did receive criticism, but was in the pre-internet days) or Matt Ruff and Lovecraft Country or Ben H. Winters and Underground Airlines.

    Maybe it’s the Oprah connection?

    Reply
  3. Scootsa1000 says

    September 20, 2020 at 12:09 pm

    I think there were several problems going on with this book launch.

    From what I understand, there were major issues with the marketing and publicity of the book —lots of barbed wire decorations (including, I guess, manicures) that people found insensitive, which led to the cancellation of the book tour.

    Oprah could have and should have picked a book about the migrant plight that was actually written by someone from one of the countries being discussed, as opposed to a woman from Pennsylvania who had easy access to publishers and a big publicity machine.

    From my perspective, the worst thing was that I just didn’t think it was any good, regardless of who wrote it and where they grew up.

    Reply
  4. narfna says

    September 21, 2020 at 1:51 pm

    I hope you at least didn’t pay money for it? I’m still mad that my book club made me pay money to read A Little Life.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.



Recent Comments

  • Nart on How many Beauty and the Beast retellings can I get through? ManyJust to clarify - is there anti Semitism in THIS book or in other James books? Because I love me a good Beauty and the...
  • Nart on “You had to hand it to the Patrician, he admitted grudgingly. If you didn’t, he sent men to come and take it away.”One of my all time favourite books and how I got my father-in-law into Terry Pratchett (he’s a funny older children’s writer, I don’t know...
  • Nart on Anna Snow…or Snow White?I totally agree. Balogh is not really a SIZZLE writer. You go to her books for achingly sweet stories about people overcoming hardships by being...
  • Bothari43 on CBR Diversions – It’s Never too Late to Have a Happy ChildhoodHa, yes! I remember my little brother once came barreling into my room, no doubt ready to torture me, and stopped short because I was...
  • Bothari43 on We’re the aliens, manI love this series (does it count as a series if it's only two?) SO much. And I read The Doors of Eden last year,...
See More Recent Comments »

Want to Help Out?

CBR has a great crew of volunteers, and we're always looking for more people to help out. If you have a specialty or are willing to learn, drop MsWas a line.

  • How You Can Donate
  • FAQ
  • Shop
  • Volunteers
  • Leaderboard
  • AlabamaPink
  • Contact

Help Our Mission

You can donate to CBR via:

  1. PayPal
  2. Venmo
  3. Google Pay
© 2021 Cannonball Read | Log in