Thank you to Simon and Schuster and Netgalley for this ARC. My opinions are my own. This book is out on May 5th, 2026.
Finley is graduating from high school, and is worried about several weeks away from her charismatic boyfriend, Colin, their friend group and her entire social circle. Most of all, she would have wanted to join Colin and his family on a Disney cruise, but her distant mother, Catherine (her father has custody and she only sees her Mum a few times a year), has declared that they are spending time together in New York City, and that the dates cannot be changed.
So imagine Finley’s surprise when she is told on the morning of their departure that New York will have to wait. Instead, they are going to her mother’s home town, Lakeview, to sell a house neither Finley nor her father knew existed. Catherine was estranged from her parents until they died, and has kept up the distance to her two sisters, but for reasons she refuses to go into, the old family home needs to be cleared out and sold as soon as possible.
Once they arrive, Finley discovers that “Cat” has been in communication with her sisters but refused to make any decisions for months, and this sudden change is a surprise to absolutely everyone.
Her aunts are very happy to see Finley again, though. She hasn’t really seen anyone from her mother’s family since her grandmother’s funeral, and that is long enough ago that she barely remembers anyone, certainly not her cousins, who are all grown up now.
Cell reception is pretty unreliable in the middle of the woods, and Finley worries that she can’t get in touch with Colin. Although when she finally does, it’s because he calls her, from the boat, to break up with her via video chat. Since Colin has been the centre of Finley’s life for the past two years, and featured in all of her plans for the future (she deferred all her other college choices to go to the same place as him), she is absolutely devastated, and shortly after, throws her phone in the lake in a fit of drunken impulsiveness.
One of Finley’s aunts co-owns a diner, the Egg, where it seems most of the teens she’s met during the last few days work. Heartbroken and without real purpose, Finley starts helping out during the breakfast rush, when most of the tourists come in to eat, and soon she’s making money and has made new friends. There’s Clark, who runs the grill, and whose now deceased father founded the Egg with Finley’s aunt. There’s Lana, who sneaks into the old house where Finlay and Cat are staying and sleeps on the couch, leaving before anyone else wakes up. She takes it upon herself to become Finley’s BFF after Colin dumps her, since she has considerable experience with romantic disappointments in her past. And finally, there is Ben, the shy guitarist who helps Clark in the kitchen and claims that he’s super awkward around new people, but seems to warm to Finley immediately.
Full review in the usual place.
