A few years ago, Theo and Kit broke up right before embarking on a three week food and wine tour of southern Europe. Now, after accidentally redeeming their vouchers for the same trip, they find themselves in close quarters as they travel through France, Spain, and Italy on a gourmand’s dream vacation. In an attempt to get over the awkwardness and maybe recapture their former friendship (the two met as children and were thick as thieves until the breakup) they decide to compete to see who can have more hook-ups on their trip. So there is, like, a lot of sex. The Pairing is definitely Casey McQuiston’s spiciest novel (and I read One Last Stop with all its train sex!) but it’s also a leisurely sumptuous exploration of the culinary scene. If you like food, wine, and sex scenes, The Pairing is the book for you.
Here’s what I liked: the descriptions of the food and wine are incredible. I felt like I was hungry the entire time I was reading this book. I also enjoyed how Theo and Kit slowly found their way back to each other, and fit together better with a few years of maturity. And the dissolution of their first romance was heartbreaking. I also appreciate the nuanced take on Theo’s gender identity, and how their story wasn’t really about coming out, but still did a lovely job exploring their emotions around it. However, I have to note that it’s hard to fully empathize with a character like Theo who is clearly struggling with feeling like a failure, but refuses all help from their family out of stubborn pride. Even if they don’t want to take advantage of their famous family’s connections, refusing all monetary support or investment just feels like cutting of their nose to spite their face.
I still think that Red White and Royal Blue is Casey McQuiston’s best work. (The excellent movie adaptation doesn’t hurt!) But The Pairing is enjoyable and has a good emotional payout. And the food descriptions are incredible.
