Bingo: Success. The two main characters are huge successes in their fields.
Hide and Seek by James Patterson is terrible by any measure. It’s poorly written (and this is when Patterson was writing his own stuff I believe and not pairing up with ex presidents and a team of ghost writers). Its female main character is an insufferable Mary Sue. The antagonist is a standard issue violent sociopath whose actions are boringly cliche. The plot feels like a rip off of Sydney Sheldon’s Rage of Angels from characters to plot to skin crawling sex scenes (Sheldon himself a third rate writer, as much as I devoured his books as a youth). Even with all this, the book eked out a second star by having a creative if improbable ending.
Maggie is a woman who saved herself and her daughter from an abusive husband and father by killing him during a violent episode. She is not charged as it was deemed self defense and she goes on to chase her dream of being a famous singer and song writer. Her talent is so immense that a successful singer and music producer takes her under his wing and before you know it everyone is unrealistically falling at her feet.
The reader is yanked to the present moment where Maggie is on trial for killing her second husband Will, a famous ex-soccer player and actor. The book takes us back and forth between the past, the current trial, Maggie’s first person account and the third person account of Will’s life and evil deeds.
Patterson likes to overuse italics to convey drama, and is fond of exclamation points to emphasize when something is notably exciting. His characters are paper thin and the pace throughout most of the book is weirdly sluggish. His dialogue is inauthentic. And lest you think I only consider Patterson a hack, I remember reading one of his books 30 years ago and finding it very suspenseful and gripping.
While the ending is patently ridiculous, I will give it points for a surprising if vastly unlikely twist and a modicum of energetic drama. But I can’t recommend this book in good conscience. It is far too stupid and poorly written.
