I had two issues with Girly Drinks by Mallory O’Meara.
- It had a very narrow and specific perspective on the way people (the readers) assume modern women drink and was full of irrelevant and dated pop culture comparisons to explain history. The book is only from 2021.
- It was poorly cited (but not poorly researched). It wasn’t easy to flip between the resources in the back and the statements in the chapters.
It was fun enough that I had no problems overlooking my issues. In fact I forgot to drink the super girly drink I poured myself to accompany the book because I had so much fun reading and learning.
What was my girly drink? A very hoppy beer; putting hops in beer can be traced to a nun named Hildegard of Bingen. Allegedly*.
People drink alcohol and have for as long as they’ve been people. Beer specifically has been tied to the evolution of early civilization. And since women are people, they drink and contribute to the history of alcohol and drinking.
Even though women cannot be stopped from drinking and making money from others doing so, it’s been attempted. At various times and places, they’ve been banned from taverns (where important things like planning a revolution happen), from brewing and distilling, and from drinking. They’ve even been denied the right to address their alcoholism. But in the end, the ways society tries to control a woman’s drinking has (or will) fail. Because people drink.
And I have a long list of these drinking women now.
Besides my new hero Hildegard, I also need to learn about Maria the Jewess, the alchemist and distiller. I’ve already learned Wikipedia calls her Mary. There’s also Moll Cutpurse (Mary Firth) – a notoriously drunk criminal, saké mogul Tatsuuma Kiyo, bootlegging Gertrude Lythgoe, and still alive rum distiller Joy Spence. Among many others.
*A Woman’s Place is in the Brewhouse by Tara Nurin is much better cited and said that using hops as a preservative is credited to Hildegard, which sounds better to me because people have been putting whatever in beer since as long as there’s been beer. I kept Nurin’s book close as I read Girly Drinks to double check things that sounded off. And nothing O’Meara said is false, as far as I could tell. Just oversimplified.

