Joyce Carol Oates presents four uneasy novellas of suspense, all of which are centered around a woman in peril, often from the male forces in her life.
Cardiff, by the Sea – 3.5 stars
Clare, an academic who was adopted as a toddler, returns to her unknown past when she unexpectedly inherits a house from her birth grandmother, but what she learns about her birth family leaves her unmoored.
I loved the prose in this novella (as I did in all of them), as well as the slow unraveling of the truth of Clare’s past, including plenty of red herrings and horrific discoveries. She’s hemmed in on all sides, and the reader too starts to feel intensely claustrophobic. However, while I did enjoy the twist of the ending, I thought it ended rather abruptly.
Miao Dao – 5 stars
After her parents’ divorce, Mia’s only friends seem to be the feral cats living behind her house. And as Mia starts to grow up, her adopted cat might be the only thing standing between her and the increasingly aggressive men and boys in her life.
This was my favorite of the four novellas. It’s spiked with some paranormal elements, though you can also make the argument that this might just be how it is presented to us. It expertly examines the uncertainty and anxiety of puberty, compounded by the harassment she faces now that she starts being perceived as a sexual figure. To me this novella was more intense because the scenario felt so realistic – except most young girls don’t have a Miao Dao.
Phantomwise 1972 – 3 stars
Alyce, a shy undergraduate, discovers that she is pregnant by a teacher, and gets entangled in the life of an older visiting poet.
This was the weakest of the collection for me, though it’s still a pretty good read. After exploring the choices Alyce faces as a single, unexpectedly pregnant woman before Roe v. Wade and the growing relationship between her and the poet, we go into a sudden action-packed ending which, while unsettling and on theme with the rest of the collection, is a jarring end to the more low-key, psychological feel of the rest of the story.
The Surviving Child – 4 stars
After Elisabeth marries a widower, she attempts to develop a relationship with her stepson, the only survivor of a murder-suicide which resulted in the deaths of his poet mother and his young sister.
This story felt like another take on the concept of the first story. You’d think two novellas about a child surviving an attempted family annihilation might echo each other too closely, but these are actually pretty different. I enjoyed the exploration of the ‘mad artist’ trope, as well as the ending of the story. However, I did think the main character Elisabeth was rather colorless, compared both to the other characters in her story as well as the leads of all other stories.
